Witch Finder

18039069Title: Witch Finder
Author: Ruth Warburton
Source: from publisher for review
Rating: ★★★☆☆
Review Summary: This was a fun, light, action-packed adventure but the anticlimactic ending and two-dimensional villain left me wanting something more.

London. 1880. In the slums of Spitalfields apprentice blacksmith Luke is facing initiation into the Malleus Maleficorum, the fearsome brotherhood dedicated to hunting and killing witches. Luke’s final test is to pick a name at random from the Book of Witches, a name he must track down and kill within a month, or face death himself. Luke knows that tonight will change his life forever. But when he picks out sixteen-year-old Rosa Greenwood, Luke has no idea that his task will be harder than he could ever imagine. (Source)

This book hooked me right away. The first two scenes, where we meet first Luke and then Rose, immediately engaged me in both protagonists lives. These scenes were tense and mysterious and I felt I got to know both characters. The book continued in the same fast-paced way it started. I was so involved I hardly took any notes! However, despite the excitement and adventure, at the end this book fell a little flat for me.

While the world was fascinating (similar to that in Born Wicked), it wasn’t fleshed out very well. For instance, Luke can see witches surrounded by an aura representing their power. That’s interesting and I would have liked to learn something about how it worked. There also weren’t a ton of details given about how the witches’ powers worked. More than that though, my biggest problems were with the villain. He’s basically evil for the sake of being evil and loving power. Oh, and he had a sad childhood. It just wasn’t enough to give him any complexity. Instead we got way more animal cruelty than I thought was necessary to show us that he was a bad person.

The ending was similarly flat. The protagonists never really confront each other about the lies they’ve told one another. They only solve the most immediate of their problems and then decide to go out into the world to face the rest together. It wasn’t even a cliffhanger, where you’re left at the end of some dramatic climax. It was more as though the author just stopped writing. Fortunately, she actually hasn’t stopped writing and there is a second book. Since I did have fun reading this one for most of the book, I’ll actually be quite excited to see if the second book fleshes out the world, the villain, and the main characters’ relationships a bit more. Because really, while it took longer to describe the flaws than the good bits, this certainly was an enjoyable read.




Filed under Fantasy, Fiction, Historical Fiction, Magical Realism

8 Responses to Witch Finder

  1. Wendy @ Wensend

    Great review. I really feel like you’ve captured what’s in the book and the book sounds great, though indeed a little flat. I reminds me a lot of the Wiccan series by Cate Tiernan.
    Wendy @ Wensend recently posted…GUEST POST | Jennine on Teaching BooksMy Profile

  2. Charlotte @ Thoughts and Pens

    I was planning to pick this book up but stopped myself due to the mixed reviews I’ve read. So far, you and one other blogger has pointed out the animal cruelty in this book. And being an animal lover, I don’t think I can handle that.

    It’s a shame because I love books that are about wizards, witches, warlocks and the likes but what should be its strongest point became one of its greatest flaws. One of the reasons that fascinates me about witch books is the magic system. It’s unfortunate that this one didn’t deliver in terms of that.

    And what a bummer that the protagonists were unforgettable. Well, at least you’re still able to get some enjoyment from this book. Some people would already ragequit the book if the protagonists are loathsome. And I get you about endings that pretend to be cliffhangery when in fact it is not. Hahahah.

    Lovely review, Katie.
    Charlotte @ Thoughts and Pens recently posted…Double Standards On ReadingMy Profile

    • Some of the animal cruelty was pretty tough to get through. I kind of skimmed one section because I couldn’t handle it very well myself.

      My favorite fantasy novels are almost always those with really well-developed, internally consistent magic system.

      I did end up enjoying the book overall, so I’ll probably give it another chane with the sequel :)

  3. Erin

    A balanced review. I’m glad you pointed out the animal cruelty stuff. Like Charlotte, I can’t see myself finding that an easy read. Thanks, great blog. :)
    Erin recently posted…Review: A World of Difference – An Anthology of Short Stories From Five Continents (Eclectic Reader Challenge)My Profile

    • That was probably my biggest complaint with this book. I felt like the author relied on the animal cruelty to convey that the bad guy was a bad guy, instead of giving him a more fleshed out motivation. It made for some tough reading and didn’t even make for a great story.

  4. shelleyrae @ Book'd Out

    Thanks for sharing your eclectic challenge review, a shame it didn’t quite work for you.

    Shelleyrae @ Book’d Out
    shelleyrae @ Book’d Out recently posted…Review: Snowblind by Christopher GoldenMy Profile


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

CommentLuv badge