Serenity: Those Left Behind

November 14, 2012 Uncategorized 2

Title: Serenity: Those Left Behind
Author: Joss Whedon et al
Source: library
Fun Fact: Adult graphic novels are actually listed as non-fiction, 741’s.
Rating: ★★☆☆☆
Review Summary: Possibly a good comic, but I’m not sure comics are my thing.

This comic is an extension of the amazing TV show Firefly, cancelled well before it’s time. I was so excited to find that the story continued! I’ve also been looking for a comic to try for my genre challenge, so it was perfect. For those of you unfamiliar with the show, it’s basically a western crossed with a space opera and follows a group of renegades from the Alliance which controls most known planets. The characters are definitely the real selling point and the show was both hilarious and awesome.

The comic is prefaced by a great letter by the actor Nathan Fillion and includes periodic divisions with drawings of the main characters. These were some of my favorite parts. Some of the drawing is good and some of it isn’t, but the majority of the story is drawn in a style I enjoyed. I especially liked that the drawing was fairly realistic, since it better captured the feel of the show. The story itself picks up with a lot of the plot points left hanging by the premature ending of the tv show, although it doesn’t resolve any of them in this first book.

Unfortunately, I don’t think comic books are really my thing. The way the writing is broken up, a little bit on each panel, made it harder for me to get into the story. I also felt like the action scenes, depicted as a series of stills, were harder to follow than either a tv show where you can watch the action happen or a book where the action is explained clearly. Finally, while the plot length was comparable to that of an episode of the show, it felt shorter and less satisfying in comic form.  I will, however, be giving a few more graphic novels and comics a chance to see if they grow on me.

Amazon|Goodreads

2 Responses to “Serenity: Those Left Behind”

  1. jmlindy422

    I will check this out. If you haven’t read “Maus,” you might find it more to your liking. It’s the graphic format, but it’s a memoir of WWII and read very much more like a traditional book. I loved it.

    • DoingDewey

      I’ll have to look into it! I did enjoy the illustrations in this one, it was just the not reading like a traditional book that bothered me, so Maus might be more my style 🙂